Selling Création De Belle - Visual Art

  • We are currently looking for new architect and police members, if you feel up to the task for either, follow the links below to apply!
    Architect Applications: Click here
    Police Applications: Click Here

ItzJazzMade

Well-Known Member
Oct 14, 2017
734
953
93
27
#21
I didnt say it has no value, since the rules said that irl cash for trade of things with Mccities goods or items is not allowed. So when I saw that since art and drawing is a skill and it dosent relate to any part of the game at all so it technically is trading irl goods/services for in game money. Which is the same concept as trading any other irl good/service for a good ingame. I get that your good at drawing but I dont get why other forms of trading isnt allowed if this is allowed. Since its all the same concept in the end. I dont have anything against your company im just clarifying things as its unfair if others cant trade irl goods or services for ingame things and that this would be allowed.
What is it that you wan't to sell? What Rl Item/good do you wanne sell for ig money?
 
Likes: CP42
Aug 24, 2017
31
51
18
#24
Oh cool, art can be sold for in game currency? That's pretty neat :D I'm so down to do that since I love drawing xD

@Death_Inferno360 I think the difference is that, art is basically work; like an arch designing a build and getting paid in game money for it. Whereas irl money is buying an advantage, and in the mojang server hosting terms, it forbids servers allowing players to gain an advantage through paying money, also known as "pay to win."

I guess since art theoretically has monetary value, it can be considered as trading money for in game currency... But hey, anyone can make art, so it's not an unfair advantage then? *shrugs*
 

Death_Inferno360

Well-Known Member
Mar 18, 2017
3,006
4,342
113
#25
Oh cool, art can be sold for in game currency? That's pretty neat :D I'm so down to do that since I love drawing xD

@Death_Inferno360 I think the difference is that, art is basically work; like an arch designing a build and getting paid in game money for it. Whereas irl money is buying an advantage, and in the mojang server hosting terms, it forbids servers allowing players to gain an advantage through paying money, also known as "pay to win."

I guess since art theoretically has monetary value, it can be considered as trading money for in game currency... But hey, anyone can make art, so it's not an unfair advantage then? *shrugs*
Not everyone can do good art tho, art can be sold for money irl, isnt it technically just in another form of a object or pice of artwork
 
Aug 24, 2017
31
51
18
#26
Yeah, it's complicated (> A <) Maybe I'm biased cuz I wanna sell art xD
Still I think selling minecraft skins is a bit different than selling alts >_> Not everyone is rich enough to spend money on a game.
Like, I think if you did someone's math homework for them (hey, there's an idea! homework help, anyone? xD) for minecraft money it's okay, but if you mailed a store bought toy to someone for minecraft money that's not okay..?? Basically services versus goods, I guess?
 

Death_Inferno360

Well-Known Member
Mar 18, 2017
3,006
4,342
113
#27
Yeah, it's complicated (> A <) Maybe I'm biased cuz I wanna sell art xD
Still I think selling minecraft skins is a bit different than selling alts >_> Not everyone is rich enough to spend money on a game.
Like, I think if you did someone's math homework for them (hey, there's an idea! homework help, anyone? xD) for minecraft money it's okay, but if you mailed a store bought toy to someone for minecraft money that's not okay..?? Basically services versus goods, I guess?
But using your services you make a good, same thing you end up trading a good with another good, and i should probs stop spamming this company thread, lets talk about this in off topic
 
#29
I didnt say it has no value, since the rules said that irl cash for trade of things with Mccities goods or items is not allowed. So when I saw that since art and drawing is a skill and it dosent relate to any part of the game at all so it technically is trading irl goods/services for in game money. Which is the same concept as trading any other irl good/service for a good ingame. I get that your good at drawing but I dont get why other forms of trading isnt allowed if this is allowed. Since its all the same concept in the end. I dont have anything against your company im just clarifying things as its unfair if others cant trade irl goods or services for ingame things and that this would be allowed.
Err, alright then.
 
Likes: DaisyDoggy
#32
But using your services you make a good, same thing you end up trading a good with another good, and i should probs stop spamming this company thread, lets talk about this in off topic
No, using the services of another does not make them a good. The services are the good. It's similar to how, say, one pays for a plane ticket. They pay for the services that the plane provides, they don't pay for the plane itself. Like this, you're paying for the services that the person performs, you're not buying the person. The provider of a service and the service itself are two very, very different things.
 
Likes: CP42
Aug 24, 2017
31
51
18
#33
No, using the services of another does not make them a good. The services are the good. It's similar to how, say, one pays for a plane ticket. They pay for the services that the plane provides, they don't pay for the plane itself. Like this, you're paying for the services that the person performs, you're not buying the person. The provider of a service and the service itself are two very, very different things.
Slavery's been abolished, can't buy people anymore xD
You can still rent them tho, and they'll do services for you :eek: In your case the service is "drawing" and the good is the "artwork".
He means that the resulting artwork that you make is a good.